Fast methods for powder rheology of sugar blends for R&D and QC using Granudrum and Granuheap

Fast methods for powder rheology of sugar blends
for R&D and QC

Granudrum Granuheap


A lot of problems in industrial processes using powders are related to the poor knowledges of the dry powder behavior.

Indeed, powder is a complex material with moving properties in time due to external factors as humidity or temperature but also due to a lot of intrinsinc powder properties such as particle size and shape, porosity, density, roughness, nature of the material,etc.

Facing all these factors, it is frequently difficult to establish a clear relationship between one or severals of these factors and the problems observed on the production line.

However, a lot of these factors have significant effects on the rheological behavior of the powder.

So, measurement of powder flowabilty and cohesion between grains (Granudrum and Granuheap) can give good and simple global views of a complex granular system.
From these information strong links can be established between simple macroscopic factors (flowability and cohesion) and behaviors observed on a process line.

Powders used or produced in industrial processes are often put in motion in the production line (blender, air convoyering, rotative furnace, mixer, blender, dryer,…).
Powder as liquid can be characterized by different behaviors following the stress applying on it or quantity of air trapped between the particles (shear thinning or shear thickening).

So, it is important to determine the rheological behavior of the powder in real conditions under motion and to evaluate the evolution of the cohesion in the material under stirring.

Then, you are able to predict and to understand the behavior of the granular material in your process.

This instrument allows to:

Classify the samples by using simple concepts based on flowability and cohesion to choose the raw materials, to optimize your process and/or your material;
Quantify the main rheological effects of the powder under motion to evaluate and predict the behavior of your material in your process line;
Control the powder properties to be sure that your process is under control at every time.

The cell of the Granudrum is a horizontal inox cylinder with glass side walls.
The capacity of the cell may vary from 10 to 100 cm3 and is half-filled with the powder sample for analyses.
The cylindrical cell rotates around his axis producing the avalanches and the flow of the grains.

For each angular velocity, several images of the Granudrum cell containing the flowed powder are recorded as controlled time-sampling.
The position of the air – powder interface is evolved by an edge detection.
The average interface position and the fluctuations around this average position are computed.

From the fluctuations of the interface and the interface, respectively cohesion of the grains powder contained inside the cell and dynamic flowability can be obtained.

The Granuheap is based on the formation of a heap of powder on a flat support.
Easy to perform and fast (60 seconds), Granuheap allows to realize large series of measurements to control a process, to analyze received raw material, to select a new furnisher or even to evaluate a new composition of blends.

Fig. 1 shows two heaps of sugar.
While the granular sugar forms a classical conical heap, the powdered sugar forms a strongly irregular heap.
Contrary to the granular sugar, the powdered sugar is strongly cohesive, due to the small size of the grains.

This example clearly shows that the heap shape strongly depends on the grain properties.
In particular, a cohesive granular material gives a high value of the repose angle and strong deviations from the conical shape.

Therefore, a precise measurement of the heap shape gives some useful information about interactions between the grains.
The angle of repose test is very sensitive to the method used to create the heap.

Therefore, an initialization protocol has been defined in the Granuheap instrument.

Moreover, after the heap formation, the measurement of the repose angle is not obvious.

The shape of the heap has to be analyzed carefully.

Fig 1 : Two typical heap shapes. (a) Conical heap shape obtained with a non cohesive granular sugar. (b) Irregular heap of powdered sugar which is a cohesive granular material

Fig.1. Two typical heap shapes. (a) Conical heap shape obtained with a non cohesive granular sugar. (b) Irregular heap of powdered sugar which is a cohesive granular material [1].

Therefore, the classical method which consists in measuring the heap height h on a circular support of diameter ø and in calculating the angle with the relation tan(α)=2h/ ø is subject to caution.

For our measurements, an initialization tube is placed on the support.
After filing the tube with the sample of powder, the initialization tube is removed and the powder flows from the tube to form a heap on the support and the handling of the powder by the operator is erased.

The support can rotate slowly around its axis.
Then, a camera is able to take pictures of the heap for different orientations.

In this way, even if the heap shape is complex and asymmetric (clay, lactose, flour powders with high cohesion), you are able to extract all the geometrical information.

From each picture of the heap, a dedicated algorithm finds the position of the interface powder/air by image analysis.
The repose angle (αr) is measured by considering the pictures of the heaps of powder.

In addition to this parameter, a cohesive index (σr) is measured.
Table 1 gives the empirical relation between the flow properties and the repose angle.

Table 1 : Empirical relation between the flow properties of a powder and repose angle


Table 1: Empirical relation between the flow properties of a powder and repose angle [1]

[1] Measuring the flowing properties of powders and grains, Powder Technology, Volume 224, July 2012, Pages 19-27


Quality control: effect of small particle size on the flowability of a coarse sugar

In industrial process, it is important to determine with the best accuracy the upper and the lower limits in which the process is under control to avoid production of non conform products.

In this example, we consider a blend of two sugars : a coarse (granular) and fine grain size (powdered) sugars.

We determine with the Granuheap instrument the maximum weight percent of powdered sugar (fine particles) to have in the coarse sugar to observe deleterious effects on powder flow-ability.

Table 2 shows the main results obtained with the Granuheap instrument for different blends of sugars.

Table 2 : main results obtained with Granuheap instrument for different blends of sugars

Table 2: main results obtained with Granuheap instrument

As we can observe in table 2, up to 4 wt % of powdered sugar, the flowability of the blend
keeps constant and it is not affected by the presence of the small particles (powdered
sugar) in the blend.
Up to 4 wt % of powdered sugar, repose angle is about 41,8° and cohesion index is about 0,8.

Above 6 wt%, we can observe that repose angle and cohesion
significantly increase (table 2).

So, powder behavior is modified by the presence of small
particles in the blend.

Above 6 wt% of fine particles, we can conclude without any doubts that powder
is characterized by a poor flow property which can have deleterious effect on the process (convoyering, packaging, sensitivity to humidity….).

So, 4 wt% of powdered sugar can be considered as the upper limit to avoid any problem on the process line.

The Granuheap instrument can be used as easy and fast control quality test to ensure that
process is under control by measuring flow-ability and cohesion of the product through
repose angle.

R&D- optimization of blend of powders (powdered milk/coffee/sugar)

Blend of powders is frequently used in food or pharmaceutical industries. In this application, the blend of powders is composed of powdered milk, freeze dried coffee and sugar in ratio 20/65/15.

Two grades of sugar and coffee, respectively coarse and fine, have been selected to show their effects on the blend behavior.

Figure 2 shows the cohesion curves obtained with Granudrum instrument for the different blends analyzed.

cohesion curves obtained with Granudrum instrument for the different blends analyzed.

Fig. 2: cohesion curve vs rotating speed for differents blends tests.

As we can observe, cohesion for blend with coarse powders is characterized by a very robust and stable behavior (no variation).

Moreover, cohesion index stays very low in all the range of rotating speeds studied.

However, replacement of coarse sugar by fine sugar (green curve) leads to an increase of the cohesion of the blend above 8 rpm.

However, up to 8 rpm, the two blends (coarse and fine sugar) are characterized by the same behavior (black and green curves).

So, if the stress applied to the blend is weak, powder rheology of the blends can be considered as similar even if fine sugar is used.

Replacement of coarse sugar and coffee by fine ones leads to a very significant increase of cohesion according to the stress applied to the blend (red curve).
Blend is characterized by a shear thickening behavior above 6 rpm.

Due to the high degree of cohesion under high stress, this powder should be more difficult to convey and to pack.

However, this powder is characterized by a low degree of segregation (fig. 3) and this factor has to be keep in mind in blend achievement [2].

Indeed, the use of fine coffee and sugar allows to obtain well dispersed coffee grains in the blend which ensures to the customer a regular taste in its coffee cup.

So, blend has to be optimized to meet customer wishes but also technical specifications on the process line.

In conclusion, the Granudrum instrument can be easily used to optimize and to understand rheological behavior of blend of powders under motion.

Moreover, the Granudrum instrument can be also use to quantify amount of additive to add in a blend of powders to improve its flowability.

figure 3 respectively coarse (A) and fine (B) sugar and coffee

Fig. 3: respectively coarse (A) and fine (B) sugar and coffee

[2] Cascade of granular flows for characterizing segregation, Powder Technology 234 (2013) 32–36